Binance
- Confidence
- 82%
- Coverage
- 82%
- Entities
- 3
- Trend
- No trend yet
Binance
VSGate
Binance vs Gate: risk and licence comparison
Compare the V1 score, evidence confidence, legal-entity coverage and all five rating dimensions. This is not a recommendation to deposit.
71Moderate Risk
Gate
- Confidence
- 78%
- Coverage
- 75%
- Entities
- 2
- Trend
- No trend yet
Five dimensions
Rating comparison
Higher scores indicate stronger evidence-backed risk controls. Open each row to review the evidence basis.
V1 calculation
How the score is calculated
The overall score is a weighted sum, not a simple average. Missing evidence lowers coverage and confidence instead of being automatically scored as zero.
25%Regulatory & legal standing15%Corporate transparency20%Asset & solvency transparency15%Security & incident history25%Operations & user protection
- 01Score each dimension from dated, traceable evidence.
- 02Apply the five published weights and calculate the weighted total.
- 03Apply redline overrides, then the confidence-based rating cap.
01
Regulatory & legal standing
55Binance
76Gate
Show scoring basis
Binance · 55/100
日本与迪拜记录有效，法国旧 PSAN 于 2026-07-02 失效；不能以历史记录代表现状。
Input confidence 94% · 0 source recordsGate · 76/100
Gate 的已核验主体和地区许可按产品分别记录；未核验范围不被概括为全球统一授权。
Input confidence 92% · 1 source records02
Corporate transparency
64Binance
70Gate
Show scoring basis
Binance · 64/100
储备与地区条款公开，但集团主体复杂且缺少公开合并财务报表。
Input confidence 78% · 0 source recordsGate · 70/100
Gate 明确披露多个独立区域主体，但全球入口仍需根据地区条款判断。
Input confidence 86% · 1 source records03
Asset & solvency transparency
85Binance
66Gate
Show scoring basis
Binance · 85/100
2026 年 7 月公开重点资产储备率均不低于 100%，并提供 zk-SNARK / Merkle 用户验证。
Input confidence 90% · 2 source recordsGate · 66/100
储备证明提供资产验证信号，但完整负债、权利负担和集团偿付能力仍不可见。
Input confidence 78% · 1 source records04
Security & incident history
62Binance
50Gate
Show scoring basis
Binance · 62/100
2019 年热钱包失窃 7,000 BTC，用户损失由 SAFU 覆盖；2026 年 SAFU 约为 10 亿美元。
Input confidence 90% · 2 source recordsGate · 50/100
历史安全事件会保留在品牌记录中；当前控制披露不能抹除历史风险。
Input confidence 84% · 1 source records05
Operations & user protection
84Binance
79Gate
Show scoring basis
Binance · 84/100
官方系统状态 API 在截点返回 normal；资产级维护仍需在充值提现页面逐项确认。 Complaint evidence remains limited and is not treated as proof of safety.
Input confidence 66% · 4 source recordsGate · 79/100
已接入官方状态页或公告入口；没有统一实时接口时会降低覆盖度，而不是自动判定正常。 Complaint evidence remains limited and is not treated as proof of safety.
Input confidence 64% · 3 source recordsOther comparisons